Direct mail in 2024? (Yes, but only if you're not an idiot about it)

Hey [Name],

Let's address the elephant: Direct mail feels weird in 2024.

Half think it's dead. Half swear it's their "secret weapon."

Truth? Direct mail is like a flamethrower. Incredibly powerful when used correctly. Incredibly stupid when used wrong.

Sending generic USB drives to 500 prospects? Expensive spam.

Sending customized package to your top 5 engaged accounts? Strategic.

The difference? Timing, relevance, and not trying to be cute.

The Hall of Shame (Don't Send These)

✗ Stress balls (it's not 2003)
✗ Cheap USB drives (security won't allow)
✗ Logo'd water bottles (they have 47)
✗ "Mysterious" packages
✗ Anything with giant logo

The Hall of Fame (These Actually Work)

✓ Books relevant to their challenge (highlight key sections)
✓ Local coffee/treats with meeting request
✓ Useful desk tools they'll actually use
✓ Charity donations in their name
✓ Experiences tied to their interests

Rule: If YOU wouldn't be excited to receive it, don't send it.

The Math Nobody Wants to Do

Typical campaign:

• Cost per send: $50-100
• Response rate: 5-10% (if targeted well)
• Meeting rate from responses: 50%
• Close rate from meetings: 20%

For 10 sends:

• Total cost: $500-1000
• Expected meetings: 0.25-0.5
• Expected deals: 0.05-0.1

Translation: You need $10k+ average deal size to make this work.

ACV $50k+? Direct mail can be goldmine.
ACV $5k? You're lighting money on fire.

Why It Works (When It Works)

Pattern interruption: They get 150 emails, 2 packages

Harder to ignore: Delete key doesn't work on boxes

Creates reciprocity: Physical gifts create obligation

Shows investment: You clearly spent time/money

But ONLY if relevant. Book about sales when they're struggling with sales? Relevant. Plastic toy because your company has "dog" in name? Trash.

My Direct Mail Playbook

Play 1: Research Package

When: After interest but gone dark
What: Industry report/book with pages marked
Note: "Chapter 7 particularly relevant to [their challenge]"
Cost: $30-40
Success: 15-20%

Play 2: Local Touch

When: High-value local accounts
What: Gift card to their favorite coffee spot
Note: "I'll be at [location] Tuesday 2pm. Coffee's on me"
Cost: $25-50
Success: 25-30%

Play 3: Problem Solver

When: You know specific pain
What: Tool that helps with their problem
Note: "Saw you struggling with [X]. This helped our clients"
Cost: $50-100
Success: 20-25%

Timing That Works

Too Early: Before any engagement = Creepy
Too Late: After they chose competitor = Desperate

Just Right:

• After 2+ email opens
• When they viewed your LinkedIn
• After positive call that didn't convert
• When timeline is "next quarter"

When Direct Mail Backfires

"Too Much" - $200 gift before talking = desperate

"Too Cute" - Puzzle boxes, treasure hunts = you're not a game show

"Too Generic" - Same gift to everyone = they can tell

"Too Pushy" - "I'll keep sending until you meet" = that's stalking

Budget-Friendly Hacks

Handwritten Note: $1, surprisingly effective
Industry Magazine: $10, shows you get them
Local Postcard: $2, personal touch
Printed Case Study: $5, tangible proof

Your Decision Tree

Should you use direct mail?

1. ACV over $10k? → Continue
2. They've engaged digitally? → Continue
3. Can personalize meaningfully? → Continue
4. Have business address? → Continue
5. Top 20 account? → Send it

Any "no" = Skip direct mail

Measuring Success

Track:

• Delivery confirmation
• Response rate
• Meeting rate
• Pipeline influence
• Cost per meeting

If direct mail costs <3x digital per meeting, keep going.
If >5x, stop immediately.

Your action items:

1. Calculate your break-even (what meeting rate makes it worthwhile?)
2. Pick your top 5 ENGAGED accounts
3. Choose relevant gifts they'll actually use
4. Write personal notes referencing specific conversations
5. Track everything

Tomorrow: Getting sales to actually follow up (the real miracle).